The largest endowments built their reputations, in part, on private markets investing. But many nonprofits operate with a very different set of resources and constraints.
Endowments under $50 million allocate about 12% of their portfolios to alternative and other strategies, a category that includes private equity and hedge funds. By comparison, endowments over $5 billion allocate more than 60%.1
For many organizations, the more relevant question isn’t how to fine-tune a private markets program. It’s whether private markets belong in the portfolio at all. The answer depends on two considerations: your organization’s liquidity needs and whether the potential benefits of private markets — diversification and access to a broader range of investments — justify the costs and potential risks.
Start with liquidity: How much cash do you need, and when?
Private markets investments require patient capital. Most funds may lock up your money for years, and you generally can’t sell on short notice. Meanwhile, your organization has payroll, programs, grants, and a spending policy to fund every year. If you operate a private foundation, the 5% minimum distribution requirement adds another consideration.
Liquidity works in two directions. Capital calls require you to send cash when a manager identifies an investment opportunity. Distributions return cash to investors, but on the manager’s schedule, not yours.
One important measure that limited partners watch is distributions to paid-in capital (DPI), which show how much cash a fund has returned relative to the capital that investors have contributed.2 Another useful measure compares distributions with net asset value, indicating how much cash is being returned relative to the fund’s remaining value.
Recently, distributions have been thin. Global private equity distributions were only 12% of net asset value through 2025, well below the long-term average of 21%.3 There are signs of improvement. Global buyout exit value jumped 47% to $717 billion in 2025.4 But even when portfolio companies are sold, it takes time for the proceeds to reach investors.
Before you consider private markets investments, ask yourself the following questions:
- Could we cover our spending and operating needs for the next three to five years without selling anything private?
- Could we meet capital calls if public markets declined at the same time?
- Can our budget withstand several years of slower distributions?
If the answer is no to any of these questions, that may point to a smaller allocation — or no allocation at all.
Diversification and return smoothing: Do private markets reduce portfolio risk?
Here’s the appeal: Private equity, private credit, and real assets can behave differently from stocks and bonds. They may introduce additional sources of return and diversify your portfolio. Over time, that mix may also make reported results appear steadier from year to year.
Some of that stability may be real. Some of it comes from how private markets are valued.
Public stocks trade continuously, with prices changing throughout the day. Private markets investment values, by contrast, are estimated by fund managers, usually once a quarter. Roughly $3.8 trillion in value sits in about 32,000 unsold companies, and the average holding period for buyout-backed companies has stretched to about seven years.5 Until those companies sell, their values remain estimates.
A smoother line on your statement doesn’t necessarily mean less risk. Market changes may simply appear later and in smaller increments because private markets investments aren’t repriced every day.
What matters to your organization is the underlying economic value and the cash available to support its mission. Ask managers how valuations are determined, who reviews them, and how past estimates have compared with actual sale prices.
Diversification may work best when private markets investments represent a measured portion of a well-constructed portfolio. Adding them on top of an already limited liquidity cushion may increase risk rather than reduce it.
Risks and rewards of private markets for smaller nonprofits
The potential rewards are real. Private markets provide access to a much broader universe of investments than public markets. Roughly 87% of U.S. companies with revenue above $100 million are privately held.6 Investors may also earn a premium over time for committing capital to less liquid investments.
But the hurdles tend to weigh more heavily on smaller organizations:
- Access to top managers: Manager selection has an outsized influence on private markets performance.7 The gap between top- and bottom-quartile private equity managers could exceed 20 percentage points. Top-quartile managers have reported annual returns of 22% or more, compared with returns of no more than 1.6% for bottom-quartile managers.8
- Costs: Private funds typically charge higher fees than publicly traded funds. Minimum investment requirements can also force smaller organizations to concentrate their portfolio commitments in just a handful of funds, limiting diversification.
- Governance and oversight: Capital calls, manager due diligence, and quarterly reporting all require time and attention. A small investment committee and a lean staff may find the additional workload difficult to manage.
- Tax complexity: Some private markets investments can generate unrelated business taxable income (UBTI), potentially creating tax liabilities for an otherwise tax-exempt organization. The implications depend on the investment structure and may require additional planning and reporting.
- Slow starts: New private funds often experience a J-curve, a pattern in which early returns are weak or negative before investments mature and gains begin to materialize. Spreading commitments across different vintage years can help manage this effect, but doing so requires time, capital, and a disciplined investment plan.
Ways to explore private markets without going all in
If you decide private markets deserve a place in your portfolio, several approaches may make participation more manageable for a smaller organization:
- Start small and build gradually. A modest allocation, committed over several years, could limit the impact of any single vintage year or investment cycle.
- Consider pooled or managed approaches. Pooled funds and outsourced investment teams may provide lower minimums, broader diversification, and professional oversight without requiring your organization to build an entire program independently.
- Explore evergreen funds. These structures often accept smaller investments and may permit periodic withdrawals. However, withdrawals are generally subject to limits and restrictions, so evergreen funds should not be confused with investments offering daily liquidity.
- Evaluate the secondary market. The secondary market, where investors buy and sell existing private fund interests, topped $210 billion in 2025 — more than double its 2023 levels.9 Secondary investments can provide a faster way to build a portfolio, sometimes at a discount to reported value. They can also offer an exit for investors looking to help reduce their existing allocations.
This is a specialized market, so evaluate the experience and pricing discipline of the buyers and sellers, transaction costs, and transparency of the process.
Should your organization own private markets investments?
There’s no universal answer. Private markets may make sense if your organization:
- Has sufficient liquid investments to cover several years of spending and operating needs.
- Has a long investment horizon and a stable funding base.
- Has the committee, staff, or outside advisor capacity to oversee the program.
- Can access quality managers and build a diversified portfolio.
They may be a poor fit if your organization:
- Relies on its investment portfolio to meet near-term operating needs.
- Has a relatively small portfolio that would be concentrated in just a few funds.
- Can’t access managers with a strong track record.
- Is uncomfortable with delayed reporting, estimated valuations, or limited withdrawal options.
For many nonprofits, a well-constructed portfolio of publicly traded stocks and bonds may be the better solution. Choosing not to invest in private markets isn’t necessarily a missed opportunity. It can be a deliberate decision to preserve liquidity, control costs, and keep the investment program aligned with the organization’s needs.
Coordinating private markets investing across your organization
If your organization does invest in private markets, it should coordinate those commitments with the rest of its financial plan. Three areas deserve particular attention.
- Investment management: Allocation size, manager due diligence, and vintage-year pacing form the foundation of a private markets program. A well-constructed portfolio may balance return potential with liquidity requirements and your organization’s capacity for oversight. Regular reviews of performance, fees, and portfolio construction help keep the program aligned with your mission.
- Spending policy: Your spending policy should account for the timing of private markets commitments and distributions. Averaging portfolio market values over several quarters can help reduce the effect of short-term market fluctuations on annual spending. For private foundations, the 5% minimum distribution requirement makes that coordination especially important. Thoughtful planning can help reduce the risk of needing to sell liquid investments at an unfavorable time to meet spending obligations.
- Tax planning: For tax-exempt organizations, unrelated business taxable income from private debt investments and certain partnership structures warrants careful monitoring. Working with tax professionals early can help identify potential exposures and account for them when evaluating after-tax investment results.
Private markets can add diversification and access to investment opportunities beyond public markets, but they aren’t right for every nonprofit. Your liquidity needs, portfolio size, governance capacity, and access to quality managers should drive the decision.
At Mercer Advisors, we help nonprofits evaluate investment strategies in the context of the organizations’ broader financial needs. We can help you stress-test your portfolio, assess whether private markets belong in it, and determine whether investing in private markets — or choosing not to — is the better decision for your nonprofit.
Providing a balanced picture of the risks and opportunities available to endowments and foundations is a key part of our role as fiduciaries.
FAQs
What does private markets investing involve?
Private markets investing involves putting capital into investments that aren’t traded on public exchanges. That includes private equity, venture capital, private credit, and real assets. These investments are typically made through funds with multiyear lockups. They offer access to an investment universe that includes roughly 87% of privately held U.S. companies with revenue above $100 million.
Should a smaller nonprofit invest in private markets?
It depends on your liquidity needs, your size, and your access to quality managers. Many private markets investments lock up money for years, so they tend to fit organizations with a long time horizon and several years of spending covered elsewhere. For many smaller nonprofits, staying in public markets may be the better choice.
Can private markets investments smooth portfolio returns?
They may. Private assets can behave differently from stocks and bonds, which may help diversify a portfolio. But part of the smoothness comes from how private holdings are valued — by fund managers, usually once a quarter — so reported results may understate the real ups and downs.
What are the risks of private markets investing?
Risks of private markets include liquidity mismatches, limited availability of high-quality assets, and high fees. Mercer Advisors CIO Don Calcagni explains how Mercer Advisors approaches these and other risks of private markets investing and how we aim to manage them. Read our CIO’s perspectives.
How do private equity valuations work?
Fund managers estimate the fair value of portfolio companies each quarter, typically using comparable public company multiples and recent deals. Unlike publicly traded investments, private equity investments don’t have daily market prices. That’s why a manager’s valuation process matters as much as the numbers do.
Explore More

Private Markets Investing: Should Smaller Nonprofits Own Them?
November 17, 2026
Grow Your Charitable Giving With Donor-Advised Funds
November 6, 2026
Year-End Giving Strategies: Helping Your Donors Give Smarter
October 13, 2026
1“Summary Asset Allocations for U.S. College and University Endowments and Affiliated Foundations, Fiscal Year 2025.” National Association of College and University Business Officers and Commonfund Institute, Jan. 2026.
2“Private Equity: Clearer View, Tougher Terrain.” McKinsey & Company, Feb. 10, 2026.
3“Private Equity Outlook 2026: Gaining Traction.” Bain & Company, Feb. 22, 2026.
4“Private Equity Outlook 2026: Gaining Traction.” Bain & Company, Feb. 22, 2026.
5“Private Equity Outlook 2026: Gaining Traction.” Bain & Company, Feb. 22, 2026.
6“Many More Private Firms in the US.” Apollo, April 20, 2024.
7“Private Equity’s Advantage Is Shifting, Not Shrinking.” BCG, Jan. 14, 2026.
8“How We Think About the Risks of Private Markets Investing: Insights From Our CIO.” Mercer Advisors, July 18, 2025.
9“What Dealmaking, Fundraising, and Investor Sentiment Reveal About Private Markets at Mid-2026.” Private Capital Global, June 3, 2026.
All expressions of opinion reflect the judgment of the author as of the date of publication and are subject to change. Some of the research and ratings shown in this presentation come from third parties that are not affiliated with Mercer Advisors. The information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed or warranted by Mercer Advisors. Content, research, tools and stock or option symbols are for educational and illustrative purposes only and do not imply a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell a particular security or to engage in any particular investment strategy. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.
Investing in private funds is speculative and will entail substantial risks. Past performance may not be indicative of future results. Therefore, no current or prospective client should assume that the future performance of any specific investment, investment strategy or product made reference to directly or indirectly, will be profitable or equal to past performance levels. All investment strategies have the potential for profit or loss. Diversification does not ensure a profit or guarantee against loss. Changes in investment strategies, contributions or withdrawals may materially alter the performance and results of your portfolio. Different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that any specific investment will either be suitable or profitable for a client’s investment portfolio. Historical performance results for investment indexes and/or categories, generally do not reflect the deduction of transaction and/or custodial charges or the deduction of an investment-management fee, the incurrence of which would have the effect of decreasing historical performance results. Indices are not available for direct investment. Economic factors, market conditions, and investment strategies will affect the performance of any portfolio and there are no assurances that it will match or outperform any particular benchmark.
For financial planning advice specific to your circumstances, talk to a qualified professional at Mercer Advisors.